SYMBOLS — WHAT ARE THEY?
By H. L. Haywood - NY Masonic Outlook May 1933.
If You Will copy off on a large sheet of paper forty or fifty of the
most widely used definitions of Freemasonry of the past two centuries
your eye will be struck by one out standing fact, perhaps it is the outstanding
fact: with few exceptions all of them take it for granted that Freemasonry
hides, conceals, or disguises its teachings behind its symbols, or at
best that they merely suggest or illustrate its meanings.
Symbols are not, and cannot be, a species of camouflage, veils, darkness—designed
to obscure or mislead. They are, and they must be, the exact opposite.
Their nature and function is not to conceal, but to reveal; not to observe,
but to express. The notion that Freemasonry employs a whole system of
symbolism solely for the purpose of withholding its teachings from its
own members has been the most disastrous blunder in the whole history
of the Craft; in the last analysis it amounts to arguing that Masonry
says one thing but means another; this weakens the force of its authority,
transforms the ritual into one long puzzle, and bewilders all except the
most learned with the unhappy feeling that they have no way of discovering
what it is that they have obligated themselves to practice and to believe.
Scientists, mathematicians, philosophers and artists, none of whom are
addicted to occultism or sworn to secrecy, employ symbols as a matter
of course. They know the human mind to be so made that symbolism is a
necessity to it; neither thought nor the communication of thought can
be carried on without it; lacking it there could be no such thing as knowledge
and therefore no such thing as science. If one were to tell any scholar,
scientist or artist that symbols are to conceal ideas he would be laughed
at for his pains; they know that symbols are themselves ideas and that
no idea can be expressed and concealed at one and the same time.
A symbol is first of all an object in its own right with its own immediate
uses and meanings. An hour glass, for example, is, to begin with, simply
an hour-glass, a species of clock, by which time is measured. A twenty-four-inch
rule is a measuring rod that every carpenter, mason or machinist carries
about with him for daily, practicable purposes. A circle drawn by a geometrician
on a piece of paper is nothing but a circle; an architect may make use
of it to construct the arch over a window, an engineer may employ it for
the purpose of manufacturing a steel pulley. Each is what it appears to
be; there is no more mystery about it than there is about a lump of dirt
or a glass of water.
At the same time each familiar object is an instance or specimen of some
general practice, or rule, or law, or idea, or principle, or truth. The
hour-glass is but one of the countless instances of the fact of time,
which operates as one of the primary and universal realities in human
experience. The rule is but one instance of the principle of measurement,
and measurement is a cardinal necessity everywhere which takes a thousand
forms—a liquid may be measured in a cup, distance is measured by
the rule, weight is measured by a scale, ignorance is measured according
to an accepted standard of enlightenment, music is measured according
to a system of beats, thought is measured by the degree of its approximation
to the truth; without all such modes and methods of measurement human
life would be impossible.
Confronted by such countless instances, with all their wide variety of
forms which may be ever changing, the mind cannot handle them all together,
but must simplify its task. It seeks out a law, principle, or idea which
rims through and controls them all and makes use of that. To do this it
seizes on some significant and familiar instance and uses it to stand
for all the other instances or as a simple form or expression of the general
truth. The moment it makes use of some one thing for that purpose, and
regardless of what that thing may be, the thing becomes a symbol. A symbol
thus stands for some general truth but at the same time it is itself an
instance, embodiment, or expression of that truth. It doesn’t hide
that truth; it expresses it, makes it plain and clear; there is nothing
artificial about its symbolical use because it is itself the truth in
Thus an hour-glass is at once a clock for measuring time and an instance
of the whole idea of time; it possesses, as symbol, a double purpose,
for it is both a clock and a representative of the general idea of all
possible kinds of clocks. A two-foot rule is in itself nothing but a measuring
stick, but at the same time it stands for the whole principle of measurement.
A circle first of all is literally nothing but a circle, but as a symbol
it becomes an expression of one of the most important of all types of
relationship, whether in the natural world or in the human world. In the
very nature of the case there cannot be anything queer, occult, hidden
or secret about a symbol because its whole being and purpose is to exhibit
something, express it, make it dear.
Nobody in his right senses will ever argue that men have all conspired
together to conceal their facts and ideas behind a veil of allegory or
to hide them in the depths of symbolism! Their motive, of course, always
is the exact opposite: to reveal, to communicate, to express, to make
clear, and if more and more they are making use of symbolism to that end
it is because symbols are so expressive, tell so much in so little, so
accurately, and with an intelligibility so universal.
There are in our ritual many elements other than symbolism—emblems,
types, dramas and allegories, but in so far as it is composed of symbols
the same things may be said of each and every one of them that has been
said in the above paragraphs about symbols in general. Their one and only
purpose is to make dear to every Mason what it is that Masonry teaches
and what is expected of him.
Freemasonry is one of the great teaching institutions like the school,
the church, the press, and similar organizations; where it differs from
them is not in its use or under standing of symbols but in its exclusive
use of a system of symbols as its method of teaching. Where they use books,
speeches, lectures, writ ten statements, creeds, all expressed in a form
of words, it uses symbols and symbols only. There are words and lectures
in our ritual but their place is not primary; their only function is to
present or to explain the symbol.
It is because this is true that symbolism is of such paramount importance
to every Mason. If he is indifferent to the symbols, does not know how
to use them, leaves them alone, makes no effort to understand them, he
must necessarily miss the whole meaning of Masonry and stand incapacitated
to be a Mason or to live its life. And a Lodge that leaves them out of
its room, or slurs them over, or treats them as quaint curiosities survived
from the Middle Ages is in so far in the real sense not a Masonic Lodge
at all, but has missed its calling and is defeating its own end. Without
its symbols Freemasonry necessarily is dumb because it has no other voice;
if its own members pass them by its influence in their lives is paralyzed
because it is through its symbols that it must operate on their minds,
if at all.
Nothing is more urgently necessary in the Craft, tragically necessary,
here or elsewhere, than the recovery—perhaps it is better to say,
the discovery of the place symbols hold in our Craft and of their proper
function in the experience of Ma sons. To teach and expound them, to require
of a candidate that he study them, to help, aid and assist worthy Master
Masons to know what they are all about— is not a side issue not
a pleasant diversion but a need so cardinal that if it isn’t done
more thoroughly than it is now there is no telling what will happen to
the Craft in the future.
Why doesn’t the Craft state its teachings in so many words and be
done with it, instead of this puzzling, roundabout use of symbols?”
This is an old question, but it is always the plain confession of a lack
of understanding of the nature of the Craft and of the method it must
always employ to effect its purpose. The answer to the question penetrates
to one of the most deeply-rooted of all the ‘secrets” of our
art. In the broadest sense of the words, and other things being equal,
a man is made a Ma son for the express purpose of causing him to study,
understand, accept and practice the symbols. They are not pointers toward
Masonry, pictures here of what Masonry is there, illustrations or commentaries
of it; they are themselves Masonry, they are what it is, they are at first-hand
and in their own right its teachings, principles, ideals.
And it is in the very process of understanding and assimilating them that
a member grows into Masonic manhood. In them he finds the life he is pledged
and called upon to live. His mind is developed by his work of studying
them. His intellect is sharpened and disciplined by the toil of overcoming
their difficulties. His imagination is enlarged and enriched by his insights
into their significance. His character is strengthened by his effort to
translate them into his own practice. His life takes shape and becomes
harmoniously ordered as he follows their lead.
Others may help him, books may instruct him, but it is for him chiefly
to use his own wits, employ his own faculties, make his own observations,
do his own reflecting, compare one symbol with another and discover how
each is related to the system as a whole; by these methods, so remote
from the easy acceptance of opinions and ideas at second-hand, which is
the curse that always dogs the use of the printed page, a man grows. He
can’t help but grow, because he is using his own faculties to some
It was for this that he was initiated in the first place; it was to engage
in this life-long labor that he was presented with Working Tools in each
of the Degrees; it was to this end that he was made a Mason. In the Craft’s
great system of symbols there stands revealed and expressed one of the
truest and mightiest philosophies of human life that our race knows anything
about; he whom Initiation has brought into its presence, and who has inherited
it by virtue of his membership, has received a possession beyond all possible
computation in any of the ten thousand terms of money or riches.
Masonic Bits and Bytes: Have any symbols been added or
omitted in modem times? A few. In old engraved certificates, most of which
depict an assemblage of symbols and emblems, you will encounter now and
then one that is no longer in use, at least in America; the chisel, for
example, the skirret, etc. The symbol of the Virgin Weeping over the Broken
Column is about one hundred and seventy years old and was devised in America.
What we call the due-guard is by many scholars believed to be also an
“Americanism.” The flag is now an officially adopted Lodge
emblem in some Grand Jurisdictions. It needs to be remembered that until
about seventy-five years ago Jurisdictions had no official, uniform ritual;
prior to that time a certain number of changes, additions and omissions
occurred here and there. But these changes, like present variations from
State to State, were in details only; in all essentials and fundamentals
the ritual has not changed for about two hundred and seventy years.